GrowthWednesday, November 18
Sarasota County will negotiate with D.R. Horton over Smith Farm after a court loss
The Daily Bradenton team
Sarasota County commissioners voted Tuesday to open settlement talks with D.R. Horton over Smith Farm, a 51-acre site across Raymond Road from the Celery Fields. The builder wants 864 apartments there; its attorney, Charlie Bailey, floated a 126-home single-family subdivision instead. The vote calls for a deal with the least impact on nearby residents.
The builder's 864 apartments dwarf the 126-home settlement option
Source: ABC7 WWSB
View as table
| Value | |
|---|---|
| Live Local apartments | 864 units |
| Single-family option | 126 units |
- Speakers: nearly 60 signed up Tuesday
- Petition: more than 2,000 signatures asking for an appeal
- Other option: county buys the property
Judge Hunter Carroll ruled Nov. 4 that the county must process the application, rejecting its April view that rural land didn't qualify under the Live Local Act. He wrote that displacing local zoning “is the very design the legislature chose.”
Smith Farm went from a county denial to settlement talks
- AprilCommissioners decide rural, residential and open-use land doesn't qualify for Live Local.
- MayD.R. Horton asks for a pre-application conference; the county declines to process the application.
- JuneD.R. Horton files its lawsuit against Sarasota County.
- Nov. 4Circuit Judge Hunter Carroll rules for D.R. Horton.
- Nov. 17Commissioners vote to enter settlement negotiations.
Sources: ABC7 WWSB, Business Observer
The ruling applies only to Smith Farm, but five other developers have filed similar suits, and at least 18 large-scale apartment projects have been proposed in rural areas under Live Local. Four of those suits are still pending before the same judge.